Maalox or Almagel: which is better, characteristics of the drugs and their differences

To compare which is better - Maalox or Almagel, you first need to understand the pharmacological properties of both drugs. Both medications belong to the group of antacids and are gastroprotectors.

Maalox and Almagel are suspensions that are used to treat acid-related pathologies of the esophagus and diseases of the digestive tract. Both medications contain aluminum hydroxide and magnesium. It is these active substances that neutralize hydrochloric acid and envelop the mucous membrane of the digestive organs, providing a healing effect. The drugs have both similar characteristics and some differences.

What is better Maalox or Almagel - comparison

The action of gastroprotectors is aimed at restoring digestive functions, neutralizing harmful toxins in case of poisoning, constipation, and diarrhea. The drugs restore the functioning of the stomach and intestines, regulate stomach acidity, and eliminate flatulence. Almagel contains benzocaine, which has an analgesic effect. Both drugs are effective in the treatment of diseases of the digestive tract and poisoning.

A comparison table will help you consider the main parameters of drugs

- discomfort and pain in the abdomen,

- abdominal discomfort after smoking, overeating and drinking alcohol,

- peptic ulcer of the stomach and duodenum,

- hiatus hernia,

- gastritis with high acidity.

Kidney failure.
Children under 15 years old.
Fructose intolerance.
Individual intolerance.
Low levels of phosphorus in the blood.

- abdominal cramps,

for a suspension in a 250 ml bottle – 366 rubles.

The price of drugs can vary within different limits and depends on the form and packaging.

Gastroprotectors neutralize hydrochloric acid in the digestive organs to the desired level and stabilize the pH of the stomach contents. The drugs form a protective shell and cover the gastric mucosa in an even layer. As a result, no carbon dioxide is produced in the organ and flatulence does not occur.

The drugs are non-toxic and are well tolerated by the body. Vomiting and other side effects may occur in case of overdose. Reviews of both medications indicate that gastoprotectors improve digestion, prevent diarrhea and constipation, and stabilize the functions of the digestive organs. Only the attending physician should decide which is better - Maalox and Almagel. It takes into account the characteristics and symptoms of the disease.

Difference between the two drugs

There are small differences between drugs that seem similar at first glance:

The difference is in contraindications. Maalox is not used in the treatment of kidney problems. Almagel is not used for liver failure.
Maalox is allowed to be used from the age of 10, and Almagel can only be used from the age of 15.
The most significant differences are in the composition of both drugs. Almagel suspension contains sorbitol, sodium saccharinate, hyaetellose, lemon oil. Excipients in Maalox are hydrochloric acid, mannitol, hydrogen peroxide, mint oil.

The main difference between the two drugs is the different proportions of the active ingredients. The drug Almagel contains a ratio of aluminum and magnesium of 3:1. Maalox contains equal amounts of aluminum and sodium hydroxide. Important! Maalox acts 2 times faster and has a longer effect than Almagel. The drug Almagel slows down intestinal motility. These features of the drugs must be taken into account in treatment.

General characteristics

The products Maalox and Almagel have similar therapeutic effects and are used in the treatment of various diseases of the epigastric region. The drugs quickly eliminate heartburn, indigestion, and remove harmful toxins from the gastrointestinal tract. Both drugs have an antacid effect and neutralize hydrochloric acid, which contains gastric juice.

Medicines include the same active substances - aluminum and magnesium hydroxides. These components stabilize stomach acidity and improve the functions of the digestive system. Gastroprotective drugs reduce the secretion of pepsin and reduce the aggressiveness of gastric juice. Both suspensions envelop and protect the gastric mucosa from negative influences.

Reviews about the use of drugs

Review #1

I have been looking for a long time for a safe medicine that would reduce stomach acidity. I have suffered from high acidity since childhood. On the doctor’s advice, I took Almagel for 2 weeks.
I drank 1 scoop 10 minutes before meals. I always try to control my diet. After starting treatment with Almagel, she noted that her health improved. Abdominal pain disappeared, stool returned to normal.

Natalya, 45 years old - St. Petersburg

Review #2

I am now drinking Maalox suspension to reduce stomach acidity. The drug acts very quickly and eliminates increased gas formation.
After taking the product, the aching pain and heartburn go away. In my opinion, Maalok is slightly better than Almagel. The drug acts very quickly and eliminates stomach discomfort.

Almagel and Maalox are medications to relieve symptoms of gastrointestinal diseases. They help eliminate heartburn, relieve abdominal pain, and reduce stomach acidity. Before choosing, you need to compare both drugs according to their effects on the body.

Comparison of Almagel or Maalox

To relieve symptoms of gastrointestinal diseases, doctors often prescribe drugs such as Almagel or Maalox. They relieve heartburn, abdominal pain, and normalize stomach acidity. Before choosing medications, you need to compare them.

To relieve symptoms of gastrointestinal diseases, doctors often prescribe drugs such as Almagel or Maalox.

General characteristics

Almagel and Maalox are gastroprotectors. They are presented in the form of tablets and suspensions. Contains aluminum hydroxide and magnesium hydroxide. Thanks to the action of the drugs, the negative effects of hydrochloric acid are reduced.

How they affect the body

Almagel helps to get rid of the irritating effect that occurs when hydrochloric acid enters the gastric mucosa and reduce overall acidity. As a result, the occurrence of heartburn, ulcers and other pathologies of the digestive organs is prevented.

The medicine has an enveloping effect, therefore reducing the likelihood of increased gas formation.

Maalox helps fight diseases of the esophagus - reflux esophagitis and effectively removes toxins from the body.

The drugs have the same effect on the body:

stabilize the functions of the digestive organs;
improve digestion;
exhibit enveloping properties;
regulate stomach acidity;
do not allow dyspeptic symptoms to develop.

Almagel should not be taken if you have kidney failure.

Difference between medications

Medicines differ in composition. Almagel contains hyaetellose and lemon oil, and Maalox contains hydrochloric acid and peppermint oil. They differ in the concentration of the main component - Almagel contains more aluminum hydroxide. This remedy is prohibited for renal failure, and Maalox is prohibited for liver disease. The first drug is produced in France, the second in Bulgaria.

Which is better - Almagel or Maalox

When choosing a medication, the doctor takes into account the type of disease and contraindications. Experts recommend Almagel if gastritis has worsened and acidity has increased, as well as for flatulence. Maalox is best used for constipation and frequent bowel movements.

Indications for use

Indications for use of Almagel:

gastritis;
duodenogastric reflux;
hiatal hernia;
exacerbation of stomach and duodenal ulcers;
colitis, enteritis, duodenitis;
pancreatitis;
pain and heartburn in the epigastrium.

Maalox is prescribed for the following diseases:

sour belching, heartburn;
reflux esophagitis;
gastroduodenitis.

Maalox is recommended for the treatment of stomach and duodenal ulcers.

How to take Almagel and Maalox

The instructions for use indicate that Almagel is drunk 1 hour after meals. The recommended dosage is 10 ml 3 times a day. After the therapeutic result occurs, the daily dose is reduced to 5 ml.

The dose of Maalox in the form of a suspension is 15 ml 2 hours after meals.

The drug is taken in tablets, 1-2 pieces. three times a day.

special instructions

Almagel is not recommended for patients with diarrhea, ileostomy, colostomy, diverticulosis, ulcerative colitis, constipation, liver cirrhosis, acute hemorrhoids. The medicine does not contain sugar, so it is approved for diabetes. Maalox often provokes constipation, and as a result of an overdose, intestinal motility is weakened.

Pregnancy and lactation

Almagel is not recommended to be taken during pregnancy and lactation, but if necessary, it is taken under the supervision of a doctor and for no longer than 6 days. Maalox is prohibited for pregnant women, but can be used during breastfeeding.

Childhood

Almagel is prohibited for up to 10 years, Maalox for up to 15 years.

Elderly age

Taking Maalox in high dosages by older people causes obstruction and intestinal obstruction. Almagel is safe for older people.

Side effects of Almagel or Maalox

Almagel causes the following side effects:

nausea, vomiting, constipation;
mood swings;
osteomalacia;
allergic reactions.

Maalox provokes the development of such adverse reactions of the body:

anaphylactic reactions;
constipation, diarrhea;
angioedema, urticaria, itching;
kidney dysfunction.

Contraindications for use

Almagel is prohibited in the following cases:

pregnancy;
hypophosphatemia;
Alzheimer's disease;
age up to 10 years.

Contraindications to the use of Maalox:

age up to 15 years;
intolerance to maltitol;
isomaltase and sucrase deficiency;
hypophosphatemia.

Effect on driving

Both medications do not affect the control of various mechanisms.

Interaction with other drugs

Almagel and Maalox, when used together with Diflunisal, fluoroquinolones, Indomethacin, antipsychotics and Ethambutol, impair the absorption of the latter from the gastrointestinal tract. Therefore, 2 hours should pass between doses of these drugs.

Alcohol compatibility

During treatment with Almagel and Maalox, it is forbidden to drink alcoholic beverages, as this reduces the effectiveness of the medications. In addition, headaches, nausea and vomiting may occur.

Overdose

When taking the medication in an increased dose, the following symptoms may occur: redness of the skin, weakness. Treatment is carried out using gastric lavage.

Conditions for dispensing from pharmacies

The drugs can be freely purchased at the pharmacy.

Storage conditions

Such medications are stored at a temperature not exceeding +25°C. They should not be frozen and should be protected from direct sunlight.

Best before date

Almagel is stored for 2 years, Maalox - 3 years.

Analogs

If Almagel and Maalox for various reasons fail to provide the desired effect, they can be replaced with the following drugs:

Ajiflux;
Sekrepat;
Gastracid;
Rennie;
Gastal;
Alumag.

Drug price

The cost of Almagel is 250 rubles, Maalox is 300 rubles.

Reviews

Svetlana, 35 years old, Moscow: “I was on a diet for a long time, which led to the development of gastritis. At first the doctor prescribed Almagel, but after 2 days an unpleasant burning sensation appeared in the stomach. Then the doctor recommended Maalox. This remedy worked well, the pain went away in 1 day.”

Dmitry, 48 years old, St. Petersburg: “I have high stomach acidity, which I have been suffering from for several years. In the last 2 months, severe heartburn and other unpleasant symptoms began to plague me. The doctor prescribed Almagel. I took it 1 scoop 2 times a day. After a week, the pain went away and the stool returned to normal. There were no adverse reactions.”

Source: https://minecraftym.ru/pankreatit/sravnenie-almagelya-ili-maaloksa

General characteristics

Both drugs are analogues in composition. They are produced in the form of a suspension for oral administration and tablets. The composition contains magnesium hydroxide and aluminum hydroxide. Antacids reduce the aggressiveness of gastric juice and eliminate discomfort in the abdomen.

How do they affect the body?

The active components neutralize the effect of hydrochloric acid and eliminate its negative impact on the gastric mucosa. Medicines help with diseases of the esophagus, stomach, and duodenum. Once in the body, the active components envelop the mucous membrane, eliminate pain and heartburn. Belching and increased gas formation disappear. The products stabilize the functions of the digestive organs.

Difference between medications

Maalox is not capable of causing constipation because it does not affect intestinal motility. It contains active components in equal quantities. The analogue contains more aluminum hydroxide. The difference is in the additional components. Maalox in liquid form contains hydrochloric acid, mint leaf oil, and sorbitol.

The analogue contains lemon oil, ethanol, hyaetellose, sorbitol. The composition of Almagel tablets is sorbitol, mannitol, MCC and magnesium stearate. Another preparation contains additional sodium saccharin, mint flavoring, sugar, starch and sucrose. Medicines differ by manufacturer. Maalox is produced by Sanofi-Aventis France (France), and an analogue is produced by Balkanpharma-Troyan (Bulgaria).

Which is better Almagel or Maalox?

For heartburn in an emergency, it is better to take Maalox. It is more suitable for elderly patients and people prone to constipation. The product acts faster and much longer. Almagel has many varieties that are good for stomach pain and flatulence.

Difference between medications

When choosing which is better: Maalox or Almagel, you should compare their composition. The active ingredients in Almagel - alhydrate and magnesium hydroxide - are contained in a ratio of three to one, and in Maalox the same substances are contained in a ratio of one to one.

This difference is important because algedrate can reduce intestinal motility, and magnesium hydroxide can increase it.

Based on this, Maalox has no effect on the level of intestinal motility, and Almagel can cause constipation and intestinal obstruction. This side effect is especially observed with long-term use, as well as in the elderly and those prone to constipation.

According to reviews, the taste of Almagel is somewhat sweeter than that of Maalox. Comparing the price of drugs is complicated by the fact that they are available in different dosage forms and volumes. An approximate comparison of the same number of drugs shows only a slight difference in cost.

General characteristics

Comparison of medicines should be carried out not only by their composition and cost, but also by their effect on the body, which is manifested in the presence of certain adverse reactions, contraindications and indications. Only a gastroenterologist can take them into account individually for each case.

Indications for use

It is necessary to take medications for the following diseases and conditions:

pancreatitis;
stomach and duodenal ulcers;
inflammatory disease of the duodenal mucosa;
displacement of the lower part of the esophagus, stomach or intestines into the chest cavity;
reflux of gastric contents into the esophagus;
indigestion as a result of taking medications;
enteritis;
duodenitis.

The remedies help eliminate heartburn, abdominal pain and belching due to poor diet and drinking alcoholic beverages.

General characteristics of drugs

Most of the indications for use:

Gastroduodenitis (inflammation of the pyloric region of the stomach and duodenum)
Heartburn, discomfort and pain in the epigastrium, with errors in diet.
Peptic ulcer of the stomach and duodenum.
Hiatal hernia (a disease in which the upper part of the stomach penetrates through the opening of the diaphragm into the chest)
Reflux - esophagitis (inflammation of the mucous membrane of the esophagus, resulting from the entry of stomach contents into the esophagus)
Manifestation and prevention of dyspepsia (discomfort and pain in the epigastrium, most often due to poor diet)

General active ingredients and excipients:

Sorbitol.
Mannitol.
Magnesium stearate.
Sodium saccharinate.

Similar contraindications:

Severe renal failure.
Hypersensitivity to components.
Fructose intolerance (due to the presence of sorbitol in the composition)
Pregnancy and breastfeeding (can only be used with a doctor's permission)

Side effects with long-term use and overdose:

Allergic reactions.
Diarrhea, constipation, nausea, belching.
Hypermagnesemia.
Bradycardia and renal failure.

The need to observe time intervals of 2-4 hours before taking other medications (may affect the absorption of certain drugs in the gastrointestinal tract, in particular antibiotics)

Both drugs are non-absorbable antacids , which means they do not cause “acid rebound” - a repeated increase in the amount of hydrochloric acid in the stomach after the drug has worn off.

How to take Almagel and Maalox?

The dosage regimen depends on the drug. The instructions contain the following information:

Maalox. Take 1.5 hours after meals, 15 ml. If pain occurs, you can drink it again after 2 hours. The maximum dose is 6 packets per day. You can switch to taking pills. They are accepted in 1 piece. three times a day. The maximum quantity is 12 tablets per day.
Almagel. The drug is prescribed in the form of a suspension or tablets. Take 1-2 tablets 2-3 times a day or 1-3 scoops three times a day half an hour before meals.

The duration of administration and dosage form are determined by the doctor.

Comparison of safety of Maalox and Almagel A

The safety of a drug includes many factors.

At the same time, in Maalox it is quite similar to Almagel A. It is important where the drug is metabolized: medicinal substances are excreted from the body either unchanged or in the form of products of their biochemical transformations. Metabolism occurs spontaneously, but most often involves major organs such as the liver, kidneys, lungs, skin, brain and others. When assessing the metabolism of Maalox, as well as Almagel A, we look at which organ is the metabolizing organ and how critical the effect on it is.

The risk-benefit ratio is when the prescription of a drug is undesirable, but justified under certain conditions and circumstances, with the obligatory observance of caution in use. At the same time, Maalox does not have any risks when used, just like Almagel A.

Also, when calculating safety, it is taken into account whether only allergic reactions occur or possible dysfunction of the main organs. In other matters, as well as the reversibility of the consequences of using Maalox and Almagel A.

special instructions

During therapy, you need to eat foods containing large amounts of phosphorus - eggs, fish, meat, nuts and beans.

Should not be taken long-term if kidney function is insufficient.

If you experience abdominal pain or dyspepsia, you should consult a doctor. If disease symptoms persist for more than 10 days, discontinue use.

Pregnancy and lactation

You can take medications as prescribed by your doctor for no more than 3 days. Long-term use is contraindicated.

Childhood

Not prescribed for children under 10 years of age.

Elderly age

Can be taken by patients in this group. In case of Alzheimer's disease, use is contraindicated because there may be an exacerbation.

Pregnancy and lactation

The disadvantages of the drug are the following: some patients are dissatisfied with the form of release of the drug and the taste is not entirely pleasant. In addition, patients do not note any other shortcomings and consider Phosphalugel an indispensable remedy for gastrointestinal disorders.

Childhood

Advantages: the drug is not contraindicated in patients with diabetes, since it does not contain sugar. In addition, in small doses it is not contraindicated in infants, and can also be used in long courses. The effect of the drug is quick and lasts up to 12 hours. Side effects and allergic reactions when using the drug occur extremely rarely. An undoubted advantage is that the drug can be purchased in one dose.

It is recommended to take Maalox with caution during pregnancy and lactation; medical supervision is necessary. The medication is permitted provided that the intended benefit to the mother outweighs the risk to the fetus. It is not recommended to use large doses and prolonged treatment. If you strictly follow your doctor's instructions, the drug can be taken during lactation.

Accordingly, to reduce stomach acidity in young children, expectant and nursing mothers, the best option is Phosphalugel. If you have a tendency to diarrhea or constipation, then it is better to choose it or Maalox. Almagel is optimal for quickly relieving stomach pain.

How they affect the body

Almagel A, for example, contains anesthesin, which relieves pain. (Phosphalugel and Almagel also have an analgesic effect by enveloping the walls of the stomach, but this is less effective.) Almagel Neo contains simethicone, which fights gas formation.

A fairly well-known representative of antacids based on aluminum phosphate is Phosphalugel. It also helps reduce the production of hydrochloric acid, soothe inflamed mucous membranes, has a sorting effect, and is indicated for dyspepsia and poisoning, all types of gastritis and ulcers. Available in the form of a citrus-flavored gel, dissolved in water or taken neat after meals. Dosage is individual. Contraindications to use include renal failure and phosphorus deficiency in the blood. It is not recommended to take during pregnancy, liver cirrhosis, or in old age.

Drug price

The price of Almagel is 200 rubles, and the analogue price is from 220 rubles.

Karina, 31 years old, Novy Urengoy

For heartburn, I always took soda, but the pharmacy advised me to buy Almagel or Maalox. Both drugs regulate stomach acidity. I don’t like taking it as a suspension, so I buy sweet chewable tablets. The drug helps cope with high acidity. The tablets begin to act within 5-10 minutes. The unpleasant sensation in the esophagus goes away, and stool returns to normal.

Anna, 26 years old, Kirov

Maalox improves the functioning of the digestive organs. Took it for stomach ulcers and high acidity. The medicine lasts up to 4-5 hours. Abdominal pain goes away quickly. I take it for hunger pangs. There is a feeling of numbness in the mouth, but then everything goes away. Does not cause constipation, unlike Almagel. While taking it, you need to follow a diet that includes foods high in phosphorus. Can be taken together with a gastroprotector, for example De-nol.

Evgeniy, 23 years old, Irkutsk

Antacids were prescribed for esophageal disease, reflux esophagitis. The drug Maalox eliminates heartburn and discomfort in the chest area. Sour belching, nausea and bloating disappear. The dosage is indicated in the instructions for use.

When symptoms such as heartburn, stomach pain, belching and other signs of dysfunction of the gastrointestinal tract appear, many people take over-the-counter antacids on their own. Antacids that neutralize hydrochloric acid in gastric juice are also often prescribed for acid-dependent diseases of the digestive system (chronic duodenitis, gastritis, pancreatitis, peptic ulcer, etc.). Some of the most common drugs in this group are Almagel and Maalox, which we will try to compare in this article.

Composition and pharmacological action of the drugs Almagel and Maalox

Both Almagel and Maalox are available in two dosage forms: oral suspension and chewable tablets. The main active ingredients in both drugs are two ingredients:

Aluminum hydroxide - helps reduce stomach acidity by interacting with hydrochloric acid in the lumen of the stomach, and also helps reduce the secretion of the enzyme pepsin by the stomach, reducing the aggressiveness of gastric juice.
Magnesium hydroxide also reacts to neutralize hydrochloric acid, producing an alkalizing effect.

Magnesium hydroxide acts quickly (after a few minutes), aluminum hydroxide - more slowly, but for a long time (within 2 - 3 hours). At the same time, magnesium hydroxide has a laxative effect, and aluminum hydroxide has a fixing effect. In addition, these substances have enveloping properties, bind bile acids and lysolecithin, which adversely affect the gastric mucosa.

The list of auxiliary components in medications varies somewhat. So, Almagel contains the following additional substances:

sorbitol;
hyaetellosis;
butyl parahydroxybenzoate;
methyl parahydroxybenzoate;
propyl parahydroxybenzoate;
sodium saccharinate dihydrate;
lemon oil;
ethanol;
prepared water.

sorbitol;
mannitol;
microcrystalline cellulose;
magnesium stearate.

The excipients in Maalox are:

hydrochloric acid;
citric acid monohydrate;
peppermint leaf oil;
mannitol, methyl parahydroxybenzoate;
propyl parahydroxybenzoate;
sorbitol, sodium saccharinate;
hydrogen peroxide;
prepared water.

sorbitol;
mannitol;
sodium saccharin;
mint flavor;
magnesium stearate;
sugar;
starch;
sucrose.

Contraindications for Almagel and Maalox

The drugs have both general indications and similar contraindications, the main of which are:

hypersensitivity to the components of the product;
significant renal dysfunction;
Alzheimer's disease;
hypophosphatemia.

Almagel and Maalox should be used with caution during pregnancy and lactation.

The main difference between Almagel and Maalox

The main difference between these drugs is that they contain active ingredients in different proportions. So, in Almagel the ratio of aluminum and magnesium compounds is 3:1, but in Maalox the amount of these substances is the same.

As a result, the following features of the drugs can be noted in relation to their effect on the body (when taking standard doses):

Maalox acts almost twice as fast and longer than Almagel.
Almagel helps slow intestinal motility.

Therefore, when choosing which is better, Almagel or Maalox, these points should be taken into account in each specific case. And, of course, it is necessary to pay attention to the list of excipients and take into account possible reactions when they enter the body.

People who suffer from diseases of the gastrointestinal tract often wonder which antacid is better - Almagel or Maalox. Each medicine has certain characteristics, depending on which you should choose one or another medicine.

Both drugs are antacids, which affect the production of gastric juice. In addition, due to their medicinal properties they are considered gastroprotectors. But they differ somewhat from each other in indications and have different amounts of active ingredients.

The structure of this drug includes two active substances - aluminum and magnesium hydroxides. The main pharmacological property of Almagel is the elimination of the irritating effect of hydrochloric acid on the gastric mucosa. With the help of this, acidity is reduced, which, without neutralization, leads to heartburn and subsequently to gastric ulcers, as well as reflux esophagitis and other severe lesions of the gastrointestinal tract.

The medication is usually considered a gastroprotector, as it has an enveloping effect and creates a protective barrier on the surface of the mucous membrane. With the help of which the stomach stops producing carbon dioxide, which stops the occurrence of increased gas formation.

“Almagel” is produced in the form of a suspension in 170 milliliter bottles in Bulgaria. This drug has several types with the inclusion of other substances that have additional effects.

The structure of this medication also includes magnesium hydroxide and aluminum algeldate. The drug is an effective antacid and has a gastroprotective effect. It protects the human body from toxins during intoxication and restores digestive functions.

The medicine is produced in France in the form of a suspension and chewable tablets. The drug in liquid form is packaged in disposable 15 ml sachets or 250 ml bottles. Tablets are produced in blisters, 20 and 40 pieces per package.

What is the difference between Almagel and Maalox? Read on.

General characteristics of these drugs:

They can regulate stomach acidity.
They have an enveloping effect.
Improves digestive processes.
Eliminates dyspeptic reactions in the intestines.
Act as gastrocytoprotectors.

The main differences between the means are as follows:

With the same composition, the content of substances differs.
"Almagel" due to its high concentration of aluminum can reduce intestinal motility, which can lead to intestinal obstruction.
"Almagel" is used according to the annotation to eliminate pathological processes in the stomach and intestines, but "Maalox" is not used for these purposes.
It has been established that the effect of Maalox occurs faster and lasts longer.

"Maalox"

What is the difference between Almagel and Maalox? Read on.

Indications for use

The main indications for the use of these drugs are:

Stomach ulcer (a defect in the gastric mucosa that occurs under the influence of hydrochloric acid).
Ulcerative lesion of the duodenum.
Hyperacid gastritis (damage to the gastric mucosa, which is caused and accompanied by increased production of hydrochloric acid).
Gastroduodenitis (inflammation of the mucous membrane of the duodenum and pyloric zone of the stomach).
Esophagitis (inflammation of the esophagus, which is accompanied by damage to its mucous membrane).
Pancreatitis (damage to the pancreas).
Lesions of the esophagus, including hiatal hernia.
Neutralization of the irritating effect of hydrochloric acid on the mucous membrane of the digestive organs.
Discomfort and pain in the abdominal area when not following a diet, after drinking alcohol, as well as fatty, spicy and salty foods.

Which is better - Almagel or Maalox? According to patient reviews, it is known that both drugs have similar actions; they effectively cope with the source that provokes stomach diseases.

Which is better: Almagel and Maalox? What is the difference? Comparison of drugs

These drugs are analogues, containing the same active components, but in different proportions, which explains some differences in their use.

Pharmacological properties

The mechanism of action of the drugs is to neutralize the acidic environment of gastric juice, suppress the activity of the enzyme pepsin, which is involved in the digestion of proteins, and protect the gastric mucosa from damaging effects. The preparations contain magnesium and aluminum hydroxides.

But if the latter predominates in the composition of Almagel, then their concentrations in Maalox are approximately equal. Since aluminum slows down the motor activity (motility) of the digestive tract, and magnesium, on the contrary, stimulates, the likelihood of developing constipation when taking Maalox is much lower.

Release form and price

Maalox:

suspension, 250 ml – 429 RUR;
susp. “mini”, 6 sachets of 4.3 ml – 147 RUR;
Susp., 30 sachets of 15 ml – 795 RUR;
chewable tablets, 20 pcs. – 282 rub.;
chewing table without sugar, 20 pcs. – 234 rub.

Almagel:

suspension, 170 ml – 220 rubles;
Susp., 10 sachets of 10 ml – 303 RUR;
suspension with anesthetic, 170 ml – 254 rubles;
susp. with anesthetic, 10 sachets of 10 ml – 344 rubles;
suspension with simethicone, 170 ml – 262 rubles;
susp. with simethicone, 10 sachets of 10 ml – 242 rub.

Which is better: Almagel or Maalox?

The drugs Almagel and Maalox can be compared to a greater extent in terms of tolerability and scope of application.

Maalox is less likely to cause constipation and nausea, since it affects the motility of the gastrointestinal tract to a lesser extent. But Almagel is allowed to be given to children from the age of 10, and Maalox only from the age of 15.

During pregnancy, the use of both drugs is undesirable due to the small number of clinical observations.

Almagel has a wider range of indications. Unlike Maalox, it can be taken for intestinal diseases, pancreatitis and to prevent stomach complications while taking anti-inflammatory drugs.

The drugs differ little in price. Some forms of Almagel are slightly cheaper than Maalox, others, on the contrary, are more expensive. The advantage of Almagel is the presence of a suspension containing an anesthetic substance or simethicone (Almagel A or Neo).

Maalox is also produced in the form of chewable tablets, which in many cases are more convenient to take, and in a low-dose version, used only to reduce heartburn and belching.

What is better, Almagel or Maalox, for gastritis?

It is difficult to say with certainty which medicine is more effective in helping with gastritis, since they have a similar effect. This largely depends on the characteristics of the individual’s body and the course of the disease.

Reviews of the use of these drugs are also very varied, but generally indicate their satisfactory effect. In terms of effectiveness, only the tablet version of Maalox is somewhat inferior in comparison with the suspension.

If gastritis is accompanied by intense pain in the stomach, then it is better to choose Almagel A, and for nausea and gag reflex - Almagel Neo.

Summarizing all the positive and negative aspects, we can present them in a short version.

How to take medications?

To use Almagel, you need to use a measuring spoon. A single dose should not exceed two spoons. The effect of the medication begins 5-7 minutes after oral administration and lasts 1-2 hours.

“Maalox” in bags before use, knead and warm in your hands. You should take no more than 6 packets or 90 milliliters of suspension per day.

The number of tablets should not exceed 12 tablets per day. For occasional use, the optimal dosage for an adult patient is 2 tablets. The medication begins to act within a few minutes and lasts 2-3 hours.

Comparison of the effectiveness of Maalox and Almagel A

Almagel A is more effective than Maalox - this means that the ability of the medicinal substance to provide the maximum possible effect is different.
For example, if the therapeutic effect of Almagel A is more pronounced, then it is impossible to achieve this effect with Maalox even in large doses.

Also, the speed of therapy is an indicator of the speed of the therapeutic action; Almagel A and Maalox are also different, as is bioavailability - the amount of the drug reaching the site of its action in the body. The higher the bioavailability, the less it will be lost during absorption and use by the body.

Side effects

Negative reactions that may occur when consuming Almagel:

Allergy.
Nausea.
Stomach colic (a symptom that can appear with various diseases and is cramping pain in the abdomen associated with intense contraction of the intestinal wall).
Spasms.
Change in color of stool.
Osteoporosis (a disease in which bone density deteriorates, causing fragility and susceptibility to fractures).

Side effects when taking Maalox:

Dyspeptic symptoms in the intestines.
Quincke's edema (a reaction to the influence of various biological or chemical factors, in most cases is of allergic origin).
Osteomalacia (a systemic lesion characterized by insufficient mineralization of bone tissue).
Excessive accumulation of aluminum and magnesium salts in the body.
Hypercalciuria (high calcium content in urine).

"Almagel"

“Almagel” is produced in the form of a suspension in 170 milliliter bottles in Bulgaria. This drug has several types with the inclusion of other substances that have additional effects.

Contraindications

Do not use Maalox if you have impaired kidney function. "Almagel" is not taken for acute and chronic kidney damage.

In addition, both medications are not used in the following cases:

Childhood. "Maalox" can be used only from 15 years of age, and "Almagel" can be used from 10 years of age.
With elevated blood sugar levels.
Glucose intolerance.

"Almagel" should be used with caution by people who have a tendency to constipation, as well as chronic diarrhea and hemorrhoids.

Almagel: reviews of the drug

Natalya: Attacks of stomach pain are extremely rare, but I am not immune from them. After another visit to the doctor, I left with a prescription for Almagel-A (it contains benzocaine, an anesthetic). I categorically did not like the taste of the suspension - it was very disgusting, but the pain was relieved in 20 minutes, there were no relapses. I now keep the bottle with me just in case.

“You can rarely find Maalox anywhere here, which is strange. I take Almagel more often; after taking painkillers, I developed an ulcer. I can’t complain about the medicine, it works well, what about constipation is true. You can’t get carried away.”

Natalia, Pyatigorsk

In this way, pain in the epigastric region is reduced and heartburn is eliminated. Both drugs work due to alegrate and magnesium hydroxide and are considered analogues of each other. But which is better - Almagel or Maalox? Or is it worth looking for a drug that has a different composition from them?

About 2 months ago, my 7-year-old child fell ill with an intestinal infection. The doctor prescribed us a number of medications, including Phosphalugel. Before this, I had never used this drug, and for diarrhea or other intestinal disorders I always gave my son Smecta.

It’s a shame I didn’t use Phosphalugel before, because the effect of its use is excellent and very fast. Literally after 2 doses of Phosphalugel, the child felt much better: stool returned to normal, nausea and vomiting disappeared.

Katerina Petrovna, 40 years old, Moscow

Just recently I suffered from food poisoning, I was already thinking about everything: high fever, repeated vomiting, diarrhea, terrible weakness, severe stomach pain. I had to call a doctor, he initially advised hospitalization, but I refused.

The doctor prescribed me a whole bunch of medications, including Phosphalugel. When I asked what kind of drug this was, since I had not used it before, he replied that Phosphalugel would help protect the gastric mucosa from irritation of the acidic environment that forms during vomiting, and also said that it would help reduce pain and relieve general intoxication.

I used all the drugs for 5 days, but I noticed improvements after the first uses of Phosphalugel. I read the instructions, it turns out that this is a very good drug that can cope with many stomach problems.

Heartburn is one of the common symptoms that torments me and my wife. Rennie was previously used as a drug to eliminate it, but recently no significant effect has been observed from it. On the recommendation of a pharmacist, I once bought Phosphalugel, which I do not regret at all.

The effect of the drug occurs in a matter of minutes, in addition, after taking it, the unpleasant heaviness and discomfort in the stomach disappears. The price of the drug is quite affordable, so it is always in my home medicine cabinet! A huge advantage of the medicine is its convenient use and pleasant taste.

During pregnancy, I suffered greatly from heartburn, initially I used Smecta, but then the doctor advised me to change it to Phosphalugel. The results from the drug are very good and surprisingly fast. After the birth of the child, I periodically suffer from heartburn and heaviness in the stomach, so I immediately take Phosphalugel.

Kirill Olegovich, 44 years old, Yaroslavl

I have been suffering from gastritis with high acidity for several years. Initially I took Almagel, but recently the doctor advised me to change it to Phosphalugel. I am very pleased with the result, I take it both during periods of exacerbation of gastritis and for heartburn, which torments quite often.

From the instructions I realized that this drug not only reduces the secretion of gastric juice, but also protects the intestines from various damage, and also removes toxins and harmful substances. After taking 1 packet of Phosphalugel, I feel relief almost immediately. I think that Phosphalugel is a “first aid” drug, my only regret is that I didn’t use it before!

We invite you to familiarize yourself with: Diet for type 2 diabetes mellitus, for a week, foods allowed and prohibited

The doctor prescribed Phosphalugel to my daughter when she was 6 months old. I still don’t know exactly what happened to her, whether it was an intestinal infection or poisoning, but she had terrible diarrhea, also vomiting and a very high fever.

The doctor prescribed Enterosgel, but at that moment it was not in the pharmacy, so he changed it to Phosphalugel. The result of the drug is very good, diarrhea stopped almost after 1 day, vomiting also stopped and body temperature returned to normal.

Now this drug is always at hand, since I myself have used it more than once for stomach pain and given it to my husband for heartburn. I consider it one of the best drugs that can solve a number of problems associated with the functioning of the stomach.